Buying a property is one of life’s biggest financial commitments—and it’s not unusual for doubts to creep in after the offer is accepted. But be warned: trying to cancel a sale without solid legal grounds can be a very expensive mistake.
A recent High Court case drives this point home. The buyer of a luxury R135 million property tried to pull out of the deal, citing “defects” in the home. The Court’s judgment makes it crystal clear: not everything you dislike about a property qualifies as a legal defect that justifies cancellation.
A Dream Home Turns into a Legal Nightmare
The buyer had made a R135 million offer on a luxury home in Sandhurst. The offer included a clause allowing the buyer to cancel the agreement if there were “structural defects or defects that are unacceptable to the Purchaser.”
The seller accepted, and the agreement was in place. But just eight days later, the buyer’s attorney sent a short email cancelling the deal, claiming that a due diligence inspection revealed issues. The buyer, it turned out, simply believed he had overpaid—and followed up with a new offer of R100 million.
The seller refused to accept the cancellation, and the matter ended up in the High Court.
Personal Preferences ≠ Legal Defects
The buyer argued that he had sole discretion to determine whether any defects were present. He initially refused to provide any specific details, and only in court did he point to minor wall cracks and a list of personal preferences—like wanting new paving, a wider driveway, a kitchen remodel, and even an elevator.
But the Court was not persuaded.
It held that a buyer’s right to cancel based on defects must be exercised reasonably, and must be based on objective evidence, not personal opinion or preferences. The buyer’s claims simply didn’t meet the legal standard.
As a result, the cancellation was declared invalid, and the buyer is still bound to the original agreement. To add to his woes, he was also ordered to pay the seller’s legal costs on a punitive scale.
What Counts as a “Defect”?
The Court clarified that a defect must be something that:
“destroys or substantially impairs the property’s utility or effectiveness for the purpose for which it is generally used.”
In other words, it must be a serious issue—something that affects the home’s value or functionality. Minor imperfections or cosmetic preferences, no matter how expensive your taste, won’t make the cut.
Our Advice
- Take your time: Don’t let pressure (internal or external) rush your decision.
- Inspect thoroughly: Get professional inspections to uncover any hidden issues—especially structural ones like damp, roof damage, or foundational cracks.
- Understand the legal wording: Be cautious of clauses that seem to give you wide discretion—they may not hold up in court.
- Get legal advice early: Before signing any offer to purchase, let us review the contract. We’ll make sure your interests are protected and that your exit clauses are enforceable if you ever need them.
At Madeleyn Inc, we’re here to guide you through every step of your property journey—because peace of mind is priceless when it comes to your biggest investment.
Adapted from ©LawDotNews
While every reasonable effort is taken to ensure the accuracy and soundness of the contents of this publication, neither writers of articles nor the publisher will bear any responsibility for the consequences of any actions based on information or recommendations contained herein. Our material is for informational purposes.